Development
SpaceX no longer needs NASA, and that's a problem for America's space agency
October 29, 2026 Development Source: Ars Technica
Share this article
To be clear, SpaceX is still fulfilling its existing contracts with NASA, the US Space Force, and other government entities. And it continues to do so at a lower cost and generally higher level of reliability than pretty much anyone else.
But the company is no longer signing many large new contracts for spaceflight services, at least in the traditional launch and in-space flight domains. The shift comes after 15 years in which the US government has grown accustomed to lower costs and rapid innovation that has revitalized the nation’s access to space.
For SpaceX and its shareholders, as shocking as it may seem for a US company to leave billions of dollars on the table in government contracts, this may be the right decision. SpaceX sees the vast bulk of its future revenue coming from artificial intelligence. However, SpaceX’s retreat from the public square comes as both NASA and the Space Force confront growing challenges from a rising space program in China and an aging but still dangerous Russia in space.
So what does it mean if the halcyon days of SpaceX riding to the rescue for America in space—such as in the saga of Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams—seem to be ending?
In the early days, Musk and Shotwell sought revenue from various sources as SpaceX developed the scrappy Falcon 1 rocket. But it was NASA that stepped in at two crucial moments in the company’s first decade.
And still, none have yet come remotely close to matching what SpaceX has done in launch, spacecraft, and in-space data services.
The relationship dynamic began to change about half a decade ago.
At the height of the pandemic, in mid-2020, SpaceX delivered a huge win for NASA by safely flying astronauts Doug Hurley and Bob Behnken to the space station. It is difficult to overstate the importance of this achievement for NASA. Since 2011, the space agency had swallowed its pride and gone, hat in hand, to Russia for transportation to the space station. Its astronauts spent months in Russia learning the language and training to ride the Soyuz spacecraft into orbit. With a single successful 64-day mission, SpaceX ended all of that.
Less than a year later, NASA again turned to SpaceX. The space agency needed a Moon lander. But Congress had only appropriated beer money for a champagne project. NASA had three options for a privately developed lunar lander. None were ideal. SpaceX’s $2.89 billion proposal to develop Starship as a lunar lander and fly two missions was the only bid that fit NASA’s budget profile. Yes, Starship presented a complicated, oversized, and technically demanding solution. But in 2021, SpaceX was NASA’s only spaceflight contractor consistently delivering big results.
Almost overnight, then, NASA’s two most important and costly programs, the Artemis Program to land humans on the Moon and the International Space Station, became utterly dependent on SpaceX.
This power imbalance continued to grow, breaking into wider public view in June 2025 amid a temporary falling out between Musk and the president he helped elect. After Trump threatened to “terminate” SpaceX’s governmental contracts and subsidies, Musk’s response was essentially so what? In return, Musk threatened to decommission the Dragon spacecraft. He knew—correctly, it turns out—that SpaceX’s role in US government space programs could not be easily replaced. A Pentagon review in July 2025 found most of the company’s contracts with the US Department of Defense were essential.
Such a future, in his mind, does not include a dead-end technology like the Dragon spacecraft—even though Dragon is the only reliable way to get humans into space outside of China and Russia, and only took flight with humans six years ago. He does not want to fly the partially reusable Falcon 9 rocket—even though it is the best, cheapest, and only Western vehicle capable of expanding to meet the growing demand from government and commercial customers for access to space right now.
Musk believes the government moves too slowly and simply isn’t ambitious enough when it comes to space. Often, in meetings at SpaceX, he will describe working with the US government as “like wearing lead shoes and walking through molasses.”
Instead, Musk wants to build bigger things, like Starship. He wants to move fast and break things when necessary. This explains why he has invested something like $15 billion in the development of the Starship rocket, from its engines to a growing number of launch sites in Texas and Florida, to get the massive, fully reusable vehicle off the ground.
For a time, this looked like a win-win situation for the US government and a growing commercial space industry counting on frequent, low-cost access to space. NASA built its Artemis Program around Starships landing on the Moon. The commercial space industry looked forward to abundant, cheap launches. The general sense was that pulling Dragon and Falcon 9 off the market would cause temporary upheaval, but these problems would soon be ameliorated by Starship and its promise of lower cost and even greater capability.
In March 2020, SpaceX published its first “Starship Users Guide,” which included a 9-meter payload fairing with a “clamshell” structure that would open once in space to deploy payloads. The company said it would support Falcon-compatible payload adapters.
But in recent years, there has been little evidence that SpaceX is actually developing such a deployment mechanism. Rather, the company has implemented a Pez-like dispenser that releases flattish satellites from a narrow door in the middle of the Starship vehicle. This serves SpaceX’s internal payloads of Starlink and future Starmind (data center) satellites. But it’s unsuitable for deploying more traditional satellites or big NASA payloads, such as large space telescopes.
Great engineers are certainly a finite resource. And SpaceX faces fierce competition in the US space industry for talented engineers, with higher salaries offered by Blue Origin, and attractive alternatives such as Stoke Space, Rocket Lab, Firefly, and Relativity Space all recruiting.
The question is whether Musk would devote his Falcon engineering team solely to Starship. Perhaps not. During the company’s third-quarter earnings call in October, Musk made a striking comment while musing about how the company aimed to deploy 10 GW of compute (on Earth) in 2027.
“What we’ve done at SpaceX is we’ve taken a team that has been able to achieve a market share in mass to orbit that is almost 90 percent,” Musk said. That team, he added, “has been able to achieve results that are an order of magnitude greater than the rest of all competitors in space combined.” Now, he said, SpaceX was applying that same team to the deployment of terrestrial compute. They would not be sent to Starbase for Starship, in other words, but to places like Memphis, Tennessee.
“This is a bit like the New York Yankees playing in Little League,” Musk said. “It’s not fair. But the net result is being able to deploy power, cooling, and infrastructure at a rate that is vastly faster than anyone else and may at some point be faster than everyone else combined.”
SpaceX can do what it wants. But there are consequences, and some people at NASA are starting to wonder how serious SpaceX is about the Human Landing System contract it won from NASA in 2021. Landing on the Moon is wholly tangential to the company’s near-term AI future, and fulfilling the contract will almost certainly be a net negative from a financial perspective.
SpaceX, of course, says it is working assiduously on a lunar lander. And publicly, NASA officials say the company is a good partner. In an interview with Ars last week, the manager of the Artemis Program for NASA, Jeremy Parsons, said he regularly visits SpaceX facilities in Hawthorne, California, and Starbase, Texas. “Their management team is definitely committed to the lunar missions,” he said. Parsons credited the SpaceX engineers working on Starship as “some of the smartest individuals” he had ever met.
No one I have spoken to at NASA, both on and off the record, says SpaceX has given them a reason to believe the company will not eventually meet its Human Landing System commitments. And to date, SpaceX has had a remarkably good track record of delivering for NASA on its contracts. Nevertheless, the road ahead may be rocky in an era when SpaceX is pulling back from government involvement.
SpaceX has consistently told NASA it must get Starship flying orbital missions regularly. It has to get to full reusability, or nothing else matters. It has to do propellant transfer. All of that must come before finalizing the lander. And sure, it’s totally fair to say that the most important thing SpaceX can do for NASA right now is getting Starship to a very high flight rate. In SpaceX’s view, in a few years, Starship will be flying so often—the company recently told the Federal Aviation Administration it plans to launch 10,000 Starships a year by the 2030s—that fueling depots for missions to the Moon and Mars will be trivial.
As SpaceX has struggled through the Starship test flight program, NASA has been waiting for an in-space fueling test, which has slipped its schedule many times. Testing propellant transfer and storage at a large scale is critical, and it has never been done in space. Successfully completing this test would reduce much of the risk for the kinds of refueling operations needed to send a fully loaded Starship to the Moon.
The latest target for such a test is “early” 2027, according to NASA and SpaceX. But this date seems aspirational. According to Parsons, the test requires one Starship to launch from Starbase in Texas and another to launch from Launch Complex 39A at Kennedy Space Center in Florida. Starship has not yet flown from there. Presently, a debut Florida launch is not expected until at least January. According to Parsons, the in-orbit fueling test is the third launch planned from Florida.
Unfortunately, to beat China back to the Moon by 2030, NASA can’t wait for Starship to reach its final form. If SpaceX were to fly a lunar demonstration in the next year or two, a necessary precursor to human landings, it probably would take something like 20 Starship launches. Starship has flown 14 times in the last three and a half years. Its flight rate will undoubtedly accelerate in the coming months, but even at a weekly launch cadence, fueling a Starship for a lunar landing would still require more than four months of dedicated launches.
Frankly, it’s difficult to envision SpaceX dedicating 20 Starships to a NASA mission anytime soon. The opportunity cost is enormous. Those same rockets could launch hundreds of revenue-generating Starlink V3 satellites into orbit. A single Starlink launch on Starship delivers the same amount of bandwidth as 10 Falcon 9 launches—bandwidth SpaceX can sell to customers for years to come. And as SpaceX expands into artificial intelligence, the company has even greater incentives to reserve Starship’s capacity for its own growing constellation of satellites.
And then there’s the financial burden. Let’s assume an unoptimized launch cost of $100 million for early Starship flights—still a phenomenally low number for a super heavy lift vehicle. At that price, a lunar landing campaign requiring 20 launches would cost approximately $2 billion in launch expenses alone. Recall that SpaceX’s original Human Landing System contract was valued at $2.89 billion and included both an uncrewed demo and crewed landing.
The actual cost of a single lunar landing mission remains uncertain, and some of the investments needed to fulfill the contract will benefit Starship more broadly. But the larger point is clear: NASA is asking SpaceX to devote substantial resources to a program that offers comparatively little financial upside at a time when the company’s own commercial ambitions are growing exponentially.
Imagine a world where SpaceX had gone all in on developing a lunar lander. Would the company be taking a different approach to the immense technical challenges of getting Starship to the Moon, perhaps with a stubby Starship variant? Would it be devoting more of its best engineers to the program? Would it consider using an expendable tanker Starship to reduce the total needed?
As it became increasingly clear that China was on course to land humans on the Moon by or before 2030, Blue Origin’s large and ambitious Blue Moon lander did not serve NASA’s more immediate needs. It would take too long.
In 2025, Ars was first to report that Blue Origin might be able to develop a lunar landing system that involved a smaller version of the Blue Moon Mark 2 vehicle and multiple transfer stages based on the existing Mark 1 lander. This involved a significant redesign to the Blue Moon program, but critically, it removed the need for in-space refueling. Eventually, this became the new plan. Blue Origin, without any guarantee of new funding, changed its design when NASA needed something faster.
“I will tell you, they are absolutely fantastic partners,” Parsons, NASA’s Artemis manager, said of Blue Origin. “They have leaned forward at every step, and they are all in on the mission.”
NASA’s upcoming Artemis III mission is illustrative of the differences.
The mission is intended to test both Blue Origin and SpaceX’s lunar landers in space. Blue Origin is building a special “test” version of its Blue Moon lander to demonstrate a host of capabilities for NASA. After docking, the crew will exit the Orion spacecraft and spend time aboard the Blue Moon vehicle. By contrast, SpaceX is pulling a “ship off the line” of its Starship program for the flight. Orion will rendezvous and dock with Starship, but there will be no ingress into the vehicle and hence no life support equipment.
Earlier this year, NASA revealed a major new initiative to develop a Moon Base. Not long after, New Glenn exploded on its launch pad. In the aftermath, Blue Origin has moved with uncharacteristic speed to repair its launch pad to get New Glenn flying again, while investing $3 billion in Florida facilities to support a much higher launch cadence.
This matters because New Glenn is superseding Starship as the essential rocket powering NASA’s lunar ambitions.
Bezos, of course, is not doing this out of the goodness of his heart or because he bleeds red, white, and blue. He stands to gain Artemis customers, national security launch contracts, and commercial business. He is chasing SpaceX’s enormous valuation with his own space company. But no one thinks Bezos would pull his rockets off the market if NASA were desperate to get to the Moon.
The real question is whether Blue Origin can succeed. The company has a long, long list of things to achieve to make Artemis a reality, from rockets to landers to in-space operations. And for all the many billions of dollars Bezos has invested, Blue Origin has a short track record of execution. It has only ever launched three orbital missions.
Now it is being called on to spearhead the landing of humans on the Moon. On a rocket that recently blew up. Aboard a lander that doesn’t yet exist. At the 11th hour.