Development
Does opting out of smart TV tracking work? Research finds “suspicious” traffic.
October 21, 2026 Development Source: Ars Technica
Share this article
The report’s findings have their limits, of course. Mammadov noted that each ACR provider and OS studied implemented ACR differently, adding:
They differed in the scenarios that trigger ACR, in how effective the opt-out is, and in the ACR modalities used. We would therefore expect TVs using ACR providers outside our study to behave differently as well, and our results should not be generalized to them. That said, our methodology is designed to be reusable.
The researchers found that the TVs running Samsung Tizen, Vizio OS (which the report refers to by its former name, SmartCast), and Roku OS continued to send network traffic to the respective ACR endpoints when user tracking was disabled in settings and when tested for specific usage scenarios, including using a first-party streaming app.
In Roku OS’ case, the tested TVs exhibited this ACR-like behavior only when using the operating system’s integrated streaming app, The Roku Channel. Further, that behavior is expected and disclosed in Roku’s terms of service and, according to the report, in the TV’s settings on TCL-branded TVs.
That’s not the case for Tizen and Vizio OS TVs, which exhibited ACR-like behavior across additional usage scenarios, as shown in the table from the report below.
Credit: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License Credit: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
“These behaviors indicate potential privacy violations; however, we cannot know for certain without access to payload content,” the report reads.
In 2017, the FTC said Vizio TVs used ACR to collect user data without consent. The company paid $2.2 million to settle the charges, saying its ACR software “never paired viewing data with personally identifiable information.” Vizio said it used the data only “in the ‘aggregate’ to create summary reports measuring viewing audiences or behaviors.”
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sued Samsung, along with Hisense, LG, Sony, and TCL, last year, alleging that they use ACR to collect personal data “unlawfully.” Samsung made opting out too difficult, the lawsuit alleged. Samsung settled, agreeing to update its terms to more clearly explain its use of ACR.
If the TVs are tracking users who declined tracking, it “would raise serious concerns about user consent and transparency,” Mammadov said. He said that is one of the most likely reasons the TVs are sending network traffic to ACR endpoints when tracking is disabled.
Mammadov noted that Roku states in its terms of service that Roku OS tracks the use of first-party streaming apps even if users opt out of tracking. “This comparison suggests that the traffic we observed on Tizen OS and [Vizio] OS may similarly reflect ongoing data collection,” he said.
Could the activity be caused by a technical bug? Even if that were the case, “the outcome for users is the same: Their opt-out choice is not reflected in the TV’s behavior,” Mammadov said.
Mammadov said another possible explanation for the ongoing traffic is that data is transmitted but discarded once it reaches remote servers. The report’s authors consider this “unlikely,” Mammadov said, adding:
Transmitting data only to throw it away is an inefficient way to honor an opt-out, since it consumes the user’s bandwidth and adds load on the vendor’s servers for no purpose. Of course, it is also impossible for us to audit independently.
“Despite its importance, little is publicly known about the privacy implications of deployed ACR implementations—in part due to the opaque nature of their deployments and challenges with automated testing,” the report says.
The size of the TV market makes dissecting ACR deployments difficult, the paper says, because doing so requires “large numbers of devices and experiments.”
Another obstacle is that “smart TVs are locked down,” making “techniques like rooting and TLS interception generally unavailable [and creating] a need instead for techniques that reliably infer ACR activity,” the report says.
Smart TV manufacturers’ persistent, opaque tracking practices have prompted more people to explore modifying their device’s software, including using a growing number of software tools designed to turn smart TVs into dumb TVs. Meanwhile, US nonprofit Software Freedom Conservancy is suing Vizio in an effort to make it easier for people to control their TV’s software, including disabling ACR.
To help people reduce the risk of their TVs tracking them without consent, the report’s authors created a list of network addresses, domains, and URLs that people can block “to prevent devices or apps from communicating with ACR services” without affecting TV viewing quality.
On the paper’s website, the researchers recommended that TV manufacturers “list every input that ACR watches, such as antenna, HDMI, apps, and screen mirroring, in the privacy policy” and “authenticate and encrypt all ACR traffic.”
The paper recommends that users remove smart TVs from their network and “use an external streaming device that does not perform ACR, or use the ACR opt-out on OSes where it was effective in our measurements.”
For tips on avoiding smart TV snooping, check out our guide on how to break free from smart TV tracking.